Quick answer
- Winner
- Carolina Panthers
- Final score
- Carolina Panthers 41–24 San Francisco 49ers
- Halftime
- San Francisco 49ers 10–24 Carolina Panthers at halftime
- FantasyHQ MVP
- S. Beuerlein
- Top passer
- J. Garcia
- Biggest EPA play
- (3:14) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad to SF 4 for 11 yards (R.McDonald).
- Game date
- 1999-12-18
Game summary
The Carolina Panthers beat the San Francisco 49ers 41–24 on 1999-12-18. S. Beuerlein posted a game-high +13.09 total EPA in the passing.
The highest-scoring period was Q1 with 27 combined points.
Line score
Final score and points by quarter.
| Q1 | Q2 | Q3 | Q4 | — | T | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 San Francisco 49ers | 10 | 0 | 7 | 7 | 0 | 24 |
 Carolina Panthers | 17 | 7 | 10 | 7 | 0 | 41 |
Scoring Map
Each pin marks where a score occurred on the field — yard line from play-by-play.
SFSan Francisco 49ers(15:00) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad for 8 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.
(12:01) W.Richey 37 yard field goal is GOOD, Center-R.Kirk, Holder-C.Stanley.
(9:15) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad for 14 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.
(2:01) R.Cunningham 21 yard field goal is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.
(1:52) J.Garcia pass to J.Rice for 48 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
W.Richey extra point is GOOD, Center-R.Kirk, Holder-C.Stanley.
(15:00) W.Floyd left tackle for 1 yard, TOUCHDOWN.
R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.
(15:00) F.Beasley left tackle for 44 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
W.Richey extra point is GOOD, Center-R.Kirk, Holder-C.Stanley.
(10:18) S.Beuerlein pass to P.Jeffers for 55 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.
(7:26) R.Cunningham 43 yard field goal is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.
(15:00) J.Garcia pass to C.Garner for 17 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
W.Richey extra point is GOOD, Center-R.Kirk, Holder-C.Stanley.
(11:28) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad for 7 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.
CARCarolina PanthersFantasyHQ Analytics
Scoring timeline
Chronological scoring plays — scroll to follow the game.
- CARCarolina Panthers
Q1 15:00TD Points+6
- Yard line
- SF 8
- Score
- 0-6
(15:00) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad for 8 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
- CARCarolina Panthers
Q1 12:01XP Points+1
- Yard line
- SF 2
- Score
- 0-7
R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.
- SFSan Francisco 49ers
Q1 12:01FG Points+3
- Yard line
- CAR 20
- Score
- 3-7
(12:01) W.Richey 37 yard field goal is GOOD, Center-R.Kirk, Holder-C.Stanley.
- CARCarolina Panthers
Q1 9:15TD Points+6
- Yard line
- SF 14
- Score
- 3-13
(9:15) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad for 14 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
- CARCarolina Panthers
Q1 5:08XP Points+1
- Yard line
- SF 2
- Score
- 3-14
R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.
- CARCarolina Panthers
Q1 2:01FG Points+3
- Yard line
- SF 4
- Score
- 3-17
(2:01) R.Cunningham 21 yard field goal is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.
- SFSan Francisco 49ers
Q1 1:52TD Points+6
- Yard line
- CAR 48
- Score
- 9-17
(1:52) J.Garcia pass to J.Rice for 48 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
- SFSan Francisco 49ers
Q1 0:24XP Points+1
- Yard line
- CAR 2
- Score
- 10-17
W.Richey extra point is GOOD, Center-R.Kirk, Holder-C.Stanley.
- CARCarolina Panthers
Q2 15:00TD Points+6
- Yard line
- SF 1
- Score
- 10-23
(15:00) W.Floyd left tackle for 1 yard, TOUCHDOWN.
- CARCarolina Panthers
Q2 12:15XP Points+1
- Yard line
- SF 2
- Score
- 10-24
R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.
- SFSan Francisco 49ers
Q3 15:00TD Points+6
- Yard line
- CAR 44
- Score
- 16-24
(15:00) F.Beasley left tackle for 44 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
- SFSan Francisco 49ers
Q3 10:18XP Points+1
- Yard line
- CAR 2
- Score
- 17-24
W.Richey extra point is GOOD, Center-R.Kirk, Holder-C.Stanley.
- CARCarolina Panthers
Q3 10:18TD Points+6
- Yard line
- SF 55
- Score
- 17-30
(10:18) S.Beuerlein pass to P.Jeffers for 55 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
- CARCarolina Panthers
Q3 8:33XP Points+1
- Yard line
- SF 2
- Score
- 17-31
R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.
- CARCarolina Panthers
Q3 7:26FG Points+3
- Yard line
- SF 25
- Score
- 17-34
(7:26) R.Cunningham 43 yard field goal is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.
- SFSan Francisco 49ers
Q4 15:00TD Points+6
- Yard line
- CAR 17
- Score
- 23-34
(15:00) J.Garcia pass to C.Garner for 17 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
- SFSan Francisco 49ers
Q4 14:55XP Points+1
- Yard line
- CAR 2
- Score
- 24-34
W.Richey extra point is GOOD, Center-R.Kirk, Holder-C.Stanley.
- CARCarolina Panthers
Q4 11:28TD Points+6
- Yard line
- SF 7
- Score
- 24-40
(11:28) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad for 7 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
- CARCarolina Panthers
Q4 7:30XP Points+1
- Yard line
- SF 2
- Score
- 24-41
R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.
Stars of the game
Top performers by total expected points added (EPA).
- 1S. Beuerlein · Carolina Panthers · Passing · +13.09 total EPA · 41 snaps · +0.32 EPA/play
- 2J. Garcia · San Francisco 49ers · Passing · +9.78 total EPA · 50 snaps · +0.20 EPA/play
- 3P. Jeffers · Carolina Panthers · Receiving · +8.41 total EPA · 11 snaps · +0.76 EPA/play
- 4F. Beasley · San Francisco 49ers · Rushing · +5.16 total EPA · 1 snaps · +5.16 EPA/play
- 5G. Clark · San Francisco 49ers · Receiving · +4.50 total EPA · 5 snaps · +0.90 EPA/play
- 6F. Beasley · San Francisco 49ers · Receiving · +4.21 total EPA · 10 snaps · +0.42 EPA/play
- 7Malik Muhammad · Carolina Panthers · Receiving · +3.56 total EPA · 11 snaps · +0.32 EPA/play
- 8J. Rice · San Francisco 49ers · Receiving · +3.40 total EPA · 6 snaps · +0.57 EPA/play
FantasyHQ Game MVP
Highest total EPA with the player's top snap and the game's biggest single play when different.
FantasyHQ Game MVP
S. Beuerlein — CAR · Passing
S. Beuerlein posted the highest total EPA (+13.09) in the game, the strongest overall impact for Carolina Panthers. Across 41 counted snaps, they averaged +0.32 EPA per play.
S. Beuerlein's top snap (-8.02 EPA): (3:14) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad to SF 4 for 11 yards (R.McDonald).
Quarterback report card
J. Garcia led all passers in efficiency for San Francisco 49ers, setting the tone in the passing game according to FantasyHQ analytics.
- J. Garcia (San Francisco 49ers) · 50 dropbacks · 58.0% completion · +0.20 EPA/play · +9.78 total EPA
- S. Beuerlein (Carolina Panthers) · 41 dropbacks · 65.9% completion · +0.32 EPA/play · +13.09 total EPA
Team stats comparison
Side-by-side offensive and defensive efficiency.
| Stat | San Francisco 49ers | Carolina Panthers |
|---|---|---|
| Offensive EPA/play | +0.144 | +0.195 |
| Offensive success rate | 44.9% | 52.2% |
| Pass EPA/play | +0.178 | +0.320 |
| Rush EPA/play | +0.049 | -0.022 |
| Defensive EPA/play | -0.195 | -0.144 |
| Defensive success rate | 47.8% | 55.1% |
Drive & efficiency notes
Carolina Panthers held the efficiency edge in offensive EPA per play (+0.20 vs +0.14), even if the scoreboard told a different story.
Season benchmark context (offensive EPA per play):
- San Francisco 49ers: +0.14 EPA/play (87th percentile vs. 1999 team-game averages)
- Carolina Panthers: +0.20 EPA/play (94th percentile vs. 1999 team-game averages)
- Carolina Panthers: 13 drives, +17.95 total EPA, 8 scoring drives
- San Francisco 49ers: 10 drives, +12.83 total EPA, 4 scoring drives
Who scored touchdowns and field goals
Every touchdown and field goal from official play-by-play.
Touchdowns
- Carolina Panthers — unlisted player
- Carolina Panthers — unlisted player
- San Francisco 49ers — unlisted player
- Carolina Panthers — unlisted player
- San Francisco 49ers — unlisted player
- Carolina Panthers — unlisted player
- San Francisco 49ers — unlisted player
- Carolina Panthers — unlisted player
Field goals
- San Francisco 49ers — unlisted player
- Carolina Panthers — unlisted player
- Carolina Panthers — unlisted player
Quarter by quarter
Quarter-by-quarter recap from live scoring plays.
The opening quarter: Carolina Panthers won the period 17–10. Carolina Panthers found the end zone from the SF 8 (Q1 15:00) — (15:00) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad for 8 yards, TOUCHDOWN.; Carolina Panthers added 1 points from the SF 2 (Q1 12:01) — R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.; San Francisco 49ers connected on a field goal from the CAR 20 (Q1 12:01) — (12:01) W.Richey 37 yard field goal is GOOD, Center-R.Kirk, Holder-C.Stanley.; Carolina Panthers found the end zone from the SF 14 (Q1 9:15) — (9:15) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad for 14 yards, TOUCHDOWN.; Carolina Panthers added 1 points from the SF 2 (Q1 5:08) — R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.; Carolina Panthers connected on a field goal from the SF 4 (Q1 2:01) — (2:01) R.Cunningham 21 yard field goal is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.; San Francisco 49ers found the end zone from the CAR 48 (Q1 1:52) — (1:52) J.Garcia pass to J.Rice for 48 yards, TOUCHDOWN.; San Francisco 49ers added 1 points from the CAR 2 (Q1 0:24) — W.Richey extra point is GOOD, Center-R.Kirk, Holder-C.Stanley..
The second quarter: Carolina Panthers won the period 7–0. Carolina Panthers found the end zone from the SF 1 (Q2 15:00) — (15:00) W.Floyd left tackle for 1 yard, TOUCHDOWN.; Carolina Panthers added 1 points from the SF 2 (Q2 12:15) — R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter..
The third quarter: Carolina Panthers won the period 10–7. San Francisco 49ers found the end zone from the CAR 44 (Q3 15:00) — (15:00) F.Beasley left tackle for 44 yards, TOUCHDOWN.; San Francisco 49ers added 1 points from the CAR 2 (Q3 10:18) — W.Richey extra point is GOOD, Center-R.Kirk, Holder-C.Stanley.; Carolina Panthers found the end zone from the SF 55 (Q3 10:18) — (10:18) S.Beuerlein pass to P.Jeffers for 55 yards, TOUCHDOWN.; Carolina Panthers added 1 points from the SF 2 (Q3 8:33) — R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.; Carolina Panthers connected on a field goal from the SF 25 (Q3 7:26) — (7:26) R.Cunningham 43 yard field goal is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter..
The fourth quarter: The quarter finished even at 7–7. San Francisco 49ers found the end zone from the CAR 17 (Q4 15:00) — (15:00) J.Garcia pass to C.Garner for 17 yards, TOUCHDOWN.; San Francisco 49ers added 1 points from the CAR 2 (Q4 14:55) — W.Richey extra point is GOOD, Center-R.Kirk, Holder-C.Stanley.; Carolina Panthers found the end zone from the SF 7 (Q4 11:28) — (11:28) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad for 7 yards, TOUCHDOWN.; Carolina Panthers added 1 points from the SF 2 (Q4 7:30) — R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter..
Turning points
Plays that moved win probability the most.
- Carolina Panthers (Q2 0:19) — (:19) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad to SF 38 for 9 yards (T.McDonald).
- Carolina Panthers (Q1 3:14) — (3:14) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad to SF 4 for 11 yards (R.McDonald).
- Carolina Panthers (Q1 15:00) — W.Richey kicks 50 yards from SF 30 to CAR 20. M.Bates to CAR 25 for 5 yards (T.Jackson).
- Carolina Panthers (Q3 10:18) — (10:18) S.Beuerlein pass to P.Jeffers for 55 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
- San Francisco 49ers (Q1 1:52) — (1:52) J.Garcia pass to J.Rice for 48 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
Impact plays
Highest EPA snaps that flipped field position.
- Carolina Panthers (Q1 3:14) — (3:14) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad to SF 4 for 11 yards (R.McDonald).
- Carolina Panthers (Q3 10:18) — (10:18) S.Beuerlein pass to P.Jeffers for 55 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
- San Francisco 49ers (Q3 15:00) — (15:00) F.Beasley left tackle for 44 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
- San Francisco 49ers (Q1 1:52) — (1:52) J.Garcia pass to J.Rice for 48 yards, TOUCHDOWN.
Every scoring play
Chronological scoring with play-by-play context.
- Carolina Panthers TD (+6) — Q1 15:00 · SF 8 · Score 0-6
(15:00) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad for 8 yards, TOUCHDOWN. - Carolina Panthers XP (+1) — Q1 12:01 · SF 2 · Score 0-7
R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter. - San Francisco 49ers FG (+3) — Q1 12:01 · CAR 20 · Score 3-7
(12:01) W.Richey 37 yard field goal is GOOD, Center-R.Kirk, Holder-C.Stanley. - Carolina Panthers TD (+6) — Q1 9:15 · SF 14 · Score 3-13
(9:15) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad for 14 yards, TOUCHDOWN. - Carolina Panthers XP (+1) — Q1 5:08 · SF 2 · Score 3-14
R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter. - Carolina Panthers FG (+3) — Q1 2:01 · SF 4 · Score 3-17
(2:01) R.Cunningham 21 yard field goal is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter. - San Francisco 49ers TD (+6) — Q1 1:52 · CAR 48 · Score 9-17
(1:52) J.Garcia pass to J.Rice for 48 yards, TOUCHDOWN. - San Francisco 49ers XP (+1) — Q1 0:24 · CAR 2 · Score 10-17
W.Richey extra point is GOOD, Center-R.Kirk, Holder-C.Stanley. - Carolina Panthers TD (+6) — Q2 15:00 · SF 1 · Score 10-23
(15:00) W.Floyd left tackle for 1 yard, TOUCHDOWN. - Carolina Panthers XP (+1) — Q2 12:15 · SF 2 · Score 10-24
R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter. - San Francisco 49ers TD (+6) — Q3 15:00 · CAR 44 · Score 16-24
(15:00) F.Beasley left tackle for 44 yards, TOUCHDOWN. - San Francisco 49ers XP (+1) — Q3 10:18 · CAR 2 · Score 17-24
W.Richey extra point is GOOD, Center-R.Kirk, Holder-C.Stanley. - Carolina Panthers TD (+6) — Q3 10:18 · SF 55 · Score 17-30
(10:18) S.Beuerlein pass to P.Jeffers for 55 yards, TOUCHDOWN. - Carolina Panthers XP (+1) — Q3 8:33 · SF 2 · Score 17-31
R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter. - Carolina Panthers FG (+3) — Q3 7:26 · SF 25 · Score 17-34
(7:26) R.Cunningham 43 yard field goal is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter. - San Francisco 49ers TD (+6) — Q4 15:00 · CAR 17 · Score 23-34
(15:00) J.Garcia pass to C.Garner for 17 yards, TOUCHDOWN. - San Francisco 49ers XP (+1) — Q4 14:55 · CAR 2 · Score 24-34
W.Richey extra point is GOOD, Center-R.Kirk, Holder-C.Stanley. - Carolina Panthers TD (+6) — Q4 11:28 · SF 7 · Score 24-40
(11:28) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad for 7 yards, TOUCHDOWN. - Carolina Panthers XP (+1) — Q4 7:30 · SF 2 · Score 24-41
R.Cunningham extra point is GOOD, Center-B.Kinchen, Holder-K.Walter.
Key takeaways
What to remember for fantasy research and follow-up box score digging.
- Carolina Panthers earned the result — use the box score for snap-level context.
- S. Beuerlein (Carolina Panthers) led total EPA — start here for highlight and prop research.
Frequently asked questions
Who won San Francisco 49ers vs Carolina Panthers on 1999-12-18?
The Carolina Panthers beat the San Francisco 49ers 41-24 in Week 15, 1999.
What was the score by quarter in San Francisco 49ers vs Carolina Panthers?
Q1: San Francisco 49ers 10, Carolina Panthers 17; Q2: San Francisco 49ers 0, Carolina Panthers 7; Q3: San Francisco 49ers 7, Carolina Panthers 10; Q4: San Francisco 49ers 7, Carolina Panthers 7; Final: San Francisco 49ers 24, Carolina Panthers 41.
Who scored touchdowns and field goals in San Francisco 49ers vs Carolina Panthers?
Carolina Panthers touchdown — unlisted player (Q1 15:00) Carolina Panthers touchdown — unlisted player (Q1 9:15) San Francisco 49ers touchdown — unlisted player (Q1 1:52) Carolina Panthers touchdown — unlisted player (Q2 15:00) San Francisco 49ers touchdown — unlisted player (Q3 15:00) Carolina Panthers touchdown — unlisted player (Q3 10:18) San Francisco 49ers touchdown — unlisted player (Q4 15:00) Carolina Panthers touchdown — unlisted player (Q4 11:28) San Francisco 49ers field goal — unlisted player (Q1 12:01, 3 pts) Carolina Panthers field goal — unlisted player (Q1 2:01, 3 pts) Carolina Panthers field goal — unlisted player (Q3 7:26, 3 pts) Extra points followed each touchdown unless noted in the play-by-play.
How did the quarterbacks play in San Francisco 49ers vs Carolina Panthers?
J. Garcia (San Francisco 49ers), 58.0% completion, +0.20 EPA per dropback, +9.78 total passing EPA. S. Beuerlein (Carolina Panthers), 65.9% completion, +0.32 EPA per dropback, +13.09 total passing EPA.
Who was FantasyHQ's player of the game in San Francisco 49ers vs Carolina Panthers?
S. Beuerlein (Carolina Panthers) was FantasyHQ's Game MVP with +13.09 total EPA on Passing plays. across 41 snaps. Their top snap (-8.02 EPA): (3:14) S.Beuerlein pass to M.Muhammad to SF 4 for 11 yards (R.McDonald)..
Season records after this game
San Francisco 49ers
Entered 4-9 Now 4-10 L
Carolina Panthers
Entered 6-7 Now 7-7 W
Fantasy · fantasyhq.co
