Colin McCarthy was drafted No. 109 overall by the Tennessee Titans in the 2011 NFL Draft out of Miami. 36 regular-season games · 1 seasons as a starter · 11 career approximate value
2011 NFL Draft · Rd 4, Pick 12 · #109 overall
Colin McCarthy Miami Draft
Colin McCarthy was drafted No. 109 overall by the Tennessee Titans in the 2011 NFL Draft out of Miami. 36 regular-season games · 1 seasons as a starter · 11 career approximate value
- Overall pick
- #109
- Round
- 4
- Draft class
- 2011
- NFL games
- 36
- Years as starter
- 1
- Career AV
- 11105th at Miami
The pick
How Colin McCarthy came off the board in 2011.
- Position
- Linebacker LB
- College
-
Miami
ACC at the draft
- Measurables
- 6'1" · 238 lbs
- Hometown
- Clearwater, FL
- Pre-draft board
- No. 102 prospect72.0 grade
- Side of the ball
- Defense
NFL career
36 regular-season games · 1 seasons as a starter · 11 career approximate value
- Games played
- 36
- Seasons as a starter
- 1
- Career approximate value
- 11105th among Miami picks
- AV with the drafting club
- 11100% of career value
- Final season
- 20132 years after the draft
Around pick 109
Who came off the board on either side of Colin McCarthy.
Georgia
Oklahoma
Missouri State
Abilene Christian
Miami in the 2011 draft
Teammates who went in the same class.
Other LB picks from Miami
The program's most accomplished players at the same spot.
Miami · Hall of Fame · 7× All-Pro · 12× Pro Bowl
#207
Jessie Armstead
LB · NYG · 1993
Miami · 1× All-Pro · 5× Pro Bowl
#12
Jonathan Vilma
LB · NYJ · 2004
Miami · 3× Pro Bowl
#25
Jon Beason
LB · CAR · 2007
Miami · 1× All-Pro · 3× Pro Bowl
#72
Olivier Vernon
LB · MIA · 2012
Miami · 1× Pro Bowl
#11
Dan Morgan
LB · CAR · 2001
Miami · 1× Pro Bowl
About this draft profile
Last updated Aug 24, 2026
Colin McCarthy in the 2011 NFL Draft
Colin McCarthy is a Linebacker out of Miami selected No. 109 overall by the Tennessee Titans in the 2011 NFL Draft. 36 regular-season games · 1 seasons as a starter · 11 career approximate value Miami has produced 265 NFL draft picks since 1980.
Where this data comes from
Pick order and career outcomes come from the nflverse draft archive; position, measurables, and conference at the time of the draft come from the college feed. Career columns stay empty until a player logs regular-season snaps.
Frequently asked questions
Where was Colin McCarthy drafted?
Colin McCarthy was selected No. 109 overall by the Tennessee Titans in the 2011 NFL Draft (Rd 4, Pick 12). Full pick detail at https://fantasyhq.co/cfb-hq/draft-history/players/2011/colin-mccarthy.
What college did Colin McCarthy play for?
Colin McCarthy played college football at Miami in the ACC. See every Miami draft pick at https://fantasyhq.co/cfb-hq/draft-history/schools/miami-hurricanes.
How did Colin McCarthy's NFL career turn out?
36 regular-season games · 1 seasons as a starter · 11 career approximate value Career outcome data at https://fantasyhq.co/cfb-hq/draft-history/players/2011/colin-mccarthy.