Ray McElroy was drafted No. 114 overall by the Indianapolis Colts in the 1995 NFL Draft out of Eastern Illinois. 81 regular-season games · 7 career approximate value
- Overall pick
- #114
- Round
- 4
- Draft class
- 1995
- NFL games
- 81
- Career AV
- 74th at Eastern Illinois
The pick
How Ray McElroy came off the board in 1995.
- Position
- Defensive back DB
- Side of the ball
- Defense
NFL career
81 regular-season games · 7 career approximate value
- Games played
- 81
- Career approximate value
- 74th among Eastern Illinois picks
- AV with the drafting club
- 7100% of career value
- Final season
- 20016 years after the draft
Around pick 114
Who came off the board on either side of Ray McElroy.
Syracuse
Stanford
Texas
Florida
Other DB picks from Eastern Illinois
The program's most accomplished players at the same spot.
About this draft profile
Last updated Aug 24, 2026
Ray McElroy in the 1995 NFL Draft
Ray McElroy is a Defensive back out of Eastern Illinois selected No. 114 overall by the Indianapolis Colts in the 1995 NFL Draft. 81 regular-season games · 7 career approximate value Eastern Illinois has produced 10 NFL draft picks since 1980.
Where this data comes from
Pick order and career outcomes come from the nflverse draft archive; position, measurables, and conference at the time of the draft come from the college feed. Career columns stay empty until a player logs regular-season snaps.
Frequently asked questions
Where was Ray McElroy drafted?
Ray McElroy was selected No. 114 overall by the Indianapolis Colts in the 1995 NFL Draft (Rd 4). Full pick detail at https://fantasyhq.co/cfb-hq/draft-history/players/1995/ray-mcelroy.
What college did Ray McElroy play for?
Ray McElroy played college football at Eastern Illinois in the OVC-Big South. See every Eastern Illinois draft pick at https://fantasyhq.co/cfb-hq/draft-history/schools/eastern-illinois-panthers.
How did Ray McElroy's NFL career turn out?
81 regular-season games · 7 career approximate value Career outcome data at https://fantasyhq.co/cfb-hq/draft-history/players/1995/ray-mcelroy.